Hitchcock's deduction that his tracks showed animals traveling in groups was one of the few attempts early paleontologists made to reconstruct how extinct animals went about their business. According to Robert Bakker, "Hitchcock's footprint evidence was very kinetic," and was nearly the only sign of the creatures in action. But because there were no bones to go with the prints, the reverend's vision of wandering flocks went unheeded. (The herding call would not be answered until nearly a century later, when Roland T. Bird would uncover a slew of sauropod trackways in Texas.)

The few bones in hand at the time did imply something about dinosaur eating habits. William Buckland's Megalosaurus, with its jagged teeth, had Gideon Mantell's vegetarian Iguanodon to prey upon, or so it was assumed, since both came from the same rock formation. Accordingly, nearly all the drawings of the time showed the two Mesozoic brutes locked in mortal combat.

A staunch creationist, Buckland believed that every creature had its God-given place in the Great Chain of Being. In one of his lectures, he is said to have bellowed, "Who rules the world? . . . The great ones eat the less, and the less, the lesser still."

This was the Age of Enumeration, when the urge to count and to classify propelled naturalists to collect with a buccaneer's avarice. The completed catalogue would spell out the divine plan for the world and reveal God's awesome creative power. What animals did was less important than their place in the grand scheme of things.